News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 My School rankings are `dangerous' 

My School rankings are `dangerous'

03 Feb, 2010 04:30 PM
SCHOOLS have no problems sharing information with parents, providing it is complete and in context, Primary Principals Association president Geoff Scott said.

Mr Scott said the use of national tests (NAPLAN) to rank schools' achievements on the My School website was too limited, because it only assessed years 3, 5, 7 and 9 and only in literacy and numeracy.

``Use of the data to compare schools can be simplistic and fraught with danger,'' he said.

``Look at the information, but please, talk to your school's principal if you think there is a problem.''

The principal of St Dominic's College, Kingswood, Jeff Regan, also warned people against relying on NAPLAN tests to rank schools.

Mr Regan also said the website was difficult to follow.

``I can't understand much of it, so I don't know how most other people are going to,'' he said.

Penrith High School parent Glenda Browne said My School was of little use to her.

``I think questions parents have are more complex, such as `How do they work with children with special needs?' rather than the simple `What's their maths score?','' she said. ``On the other hand I tend to think that information should be available the challenge is to ensure that it is used well.''

Mr Scott said the website also failed to note that some schools were wealthier than others and able to provide their students with more resources.

Education Minister Julia Gillard

defended the use of NAPLAN tests, saying they provided the best possible guide to students' literacy and numeracy skills.

``My School is not a league table and does not have any mechanisms to create league tables,'' she said.

``If we know which schools are struggling, we have new money and new targeted programs to ensure every one of our schools is a great school and every kid is getting a world-class education.''

What do you think of the My School site?

Tell us on penrithstar.com.au

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The My School website is a tool to be used to assess specific areas of school performance. As with all tools, they should be used with care and the user should be aware of its benefits and limitations. At least we now have something (albeit with limitations) to assess how each school is addressing the education issue. One of the problems is that the general public (and the government) have lost sight of the fact that education starts at home, and that the parents and family are in fact the PRIMARY educators, not the schools. The schools are there to assist with this God-given duty of educating our children. Because this fact is "lost" in modern society (and directionless families), reaction to tools such as the My School website are given to much emphasis.
Posted by Michael, 4/02/2010 9:23:17 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

penrith advisory centre
 
 
click here
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...